Judge Bowers : what is your verdict?

His Honour Judge Bowers has caused a furore, and the press are enjoying a feeding frenzy concerning his comments about burglary and bravery.

Without a transcript, we do not know precisely what he said, and more importantly, the special context of his remarks. Sentencing comments do have a dual role – a message to the public about the crime – and a message to the offender about their behaviour and how it impacts on society. It may be that Judge Bowers on this occasion, has got the balance wrong, or misjudged his audience.

Contrary to the press reporting, Judge Bowers’ comments in no way condoned burglary, nor applauded a perpetrator. Judge Bowers is known as a resolute sentencer and a mile from a soft touch. His reputation is for sound common sense and safe, realistic  judgment.

The purpose of this part of his sentencing remarks was not to excuse or condone the acts of burglars. It was aimed specifically at Richard Rochford, sending this message to him:- ‘if you have the courage/capacity to commit a heinous crime like this, you should have the courage/capacity to change your ways’.

Whilst society expects most offenders to self-determine their rehabilitation, my thirty three years of experience of criminal justice says otherwise. One of the most testing and difficult changes for a re-offender is the decision to quit. Offending frequently becomes a lifestyle for criminals, trapped by weakness, insignificance, life experience, drug dependence or peer group. Such offenders stand little chance of escape from crime. Their criminal lifestyle is self-perpetuating, whilst society looks on – administering deserved punishment but without offering solutions.

This is why re-offending in a prison-obsessed society is so high. It is also why on the whole, prisons cannot work. Being confined to a cell, exercising and socialising with other criminals is not a good recipe to bring about change. Community sentences attempt to address this, and have some success – certainly better than incarceration with other offenders. Britain has an unusually high prison population, which over many decades, has not reduced offending. For that, one needs to look to other social measures.

I sense that the message Judge Bowers wanted to convey was that as this particular offender was clearly not daunted by the sheer risk of committing the crime, he should have sufficient courage to tackle the hazardous and testing task of his own rehabilitation.  In speaking about courage, Judge Bowers sought to harness Rochford’s strengths for ‘good’ rather than ‘evil’ – for rehabilitation rather than re-offending. This is a sensible message to an offender. But perhaps it was too subtle for the media to grasp?

When the press has moved on to new news, and politicians have ceased to posture, perhaps then we can explore the real debate that Judge Bowers’ starting pistol has triggered. What is the true role for prison, why does it not provide sufficient benefits for the public, and how can it be made to work? It is notable that, in the aftermath of Judge Bowers’ remarks, no one seems willing to seize that particular nettle.


4 comments on “Judge Bowers : what is your verdict?

  1. Norm Keilty says:

    In my opinion the whole justice system needs reformed. Society is changing on an epic scale. The prison system is outdated , overcrowded and does not work. It is also costing a fortune to run. Whatever Judge Bowers did say – and indeed whatever the context was – surely a man in his position with his experience should realise that he needs to be ultra careful in case he is mis- quoted?

  2. Norm – you make a good point. As lawyers, we especially should measure our comments with care, and understand the ways in which they can be interpreted and misrepresented. But, we all know that it is hard to get things right 100% of the time. Maybe this is one fairly isolated occasion when Judge Bowers has lacked his usual care. I should add, for the purpose of clarity, that my stance here is somewhat unusual: I normally spend my time challenging judges, rather than supporting them!

  3. Wood Schofield says:

    This is a very interesting debate. I wondered what possible reason Judge Bowers could have had to say publically that a criminal had courage? Like you, Stephen, I thought he must have been addressing the criminal and encouraging him to use his courage for good. As you said, we have no transcipt but even if we did I suspect the press would deliberately extract the choicest morcels from the Judges comments to help sell their papers. The press have a huge responsibility and I think society is worse for sensational that lacks integrity.

    I think the press is the least worst option for newspapers in this country in the same way I believe that parliament is the least worst option for our democracy. I wish the press could be more balanced, fair, restrained in their appetite for splashy and gossipy headlines. The way they treated the McCann family was outrageous and is all the evidence I need to make my point that papers will use the most juicy elements of a story to help sell their papers.

    As for criminals …. we have turned our backs on them. We are scared to face them, meet them where they are at and really find out who they are and what makes them tick. Perhaps I am just talking about myself although I have been inside Dartmoor and Durham prisons more than once but that was some time ago now. I know that there is amazing work being done within the system but I fear it is small compared to the enormity of the task. I think we live boxed-in lives that protect us from inconvenience and what we find seriously inconvenient or worse we box-in somewhere else.

  4. Another first class article by David Allen Green, Legal Correspondent of the New Statesman. Follow the link

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s